EDITORIAL -- Officials in the Office of Asset Management of the U.S. Department and Housing and Urban Development appear to be asleep at the wheel. Inman News published a shocking article yesterday titled "Investor fraud grows in HUD real estate sales...More investor buyers pose as non-investors" by Glenn Roberts. The information was based primarily upon a series of articles published in TheREALTYgram Blogger.
Here is the most shocking quote gleaned from Roberts' piece:
"According to HUD statistics, there were 14 cases last year that were investigated as possible HUD Homes eligibility violations, and four sanctions issued. In 2003, there were 20 cases investigated and 13 sanctions issued, in 2002 there were 14 cases investigated and five sanctions issued, and in 2001 there were 12 cases investigated and five sanctions issued...While owner-occupant buyers are supposed to live in a property for a year after purchase, Laurie Maggiano, deputy director of the Office of Asset Management for HUD said it is a difficult rule to enforce. "We probably wouldn't even know about it," she said, if the owners resell the house within a year."
By its own admission, HUD cites a mere 27 sanctions for fraud nationally in four years! In the Lehigh Valley (PA) alone, there were more than 30 cases of investor fraud in the last year alone, according to investigative experts who have been in contact with us since TheREALTYgram Blogger broke the story in February, 2005. Those cases involve buyers of "multiple" HUD homes as well as real estate licensees. Sources close to the Lehigh Valley investigations report that complaints have been filed with HUD's asset managers for the region as well as with HUD.
None of the sanctions Maggiano references can be found in HUD's audit reports, which include disciplinary reports for all other types of HUD fraud. What are the nature of these "sanctions"? Language on the HUD Agreement of Sale warns of $250,000 fine and imprisonment for offenders. Did these sanctions include fines and/or imprisonment?
Maggiano's comments demonstrate an attitude at HUD that fosters, aids, and abets the continuing practice of fraud in the HUD Homes For Sale program. It's time to get the HUD Homes For Sale program back on track.
Recent Comments